See if we can get the fire going again!! KS, 158 posts with many stating opinions on what is best and many bad mouthing the other guys opinions and you ask what should I buy. Some where along the line you will have to make the call yourself unless you want to read another 158 posts on what others opinions are. Each person has a choice that fits the type of hunting they do. Factors like where you live, fields you hunt, $$ to spend all have a say. If I lived in SD I may use FBs as you would know the local conditions but to travel pulling a huge trailor to get out to where ever and find all mud would be disapointing. Buy what fits your hunting needs and or what you like. In the end it is your money being spent. If after using something and not liking it, sell it and try something else. Had your question been what kind of dog to buy and one said lab, one said chessie and one said golden but 150 said poodle, would you buy the poodle? I would dought it. It"s the same with decoys. Buy what you want.