No, I didn't shoot the #3 steel load in a more open choke, but I did shoot the #4 steel load with a factory flush Rem-choke (.037" constriction). It produced a slightly reduced (more open) pattern and a reduction in S/CV hits.
I didn't try a lot of different chokes since I was evaluation 20+...
I'm a little late to this discussion but here are my thoughts. I wouldn't say similar or better performance, but the below listed #4 steel load will kill a turkey within its proven distance.
I would go with steel #4s, a tight choke, and keep your head/neck shots inside of 40 yards. Of course...
I may not be of much help to you since I don't have any .410 recipes for steel loads, but I have shot a fair number of rail with .410 Win. 3-inch 3/8-ounce #6 steel loads and some with Fed. 3-inch 3/8-ounce #7 steel loads. I would prefer the #7 steel load but I have more of the Win. #6 steel...
Here are a few of my shot shell component and patterning numbers from a few low-cost lead target loads that address that statement.
Lots of numbers here but I'm sure you can sort it out. I'm just the messenger so now you can be the judge!
I recently dissected and patterned these low-cost...
I agree with Squaller. If you have access to #4 steel, I would be using it over the #3 steel.
Here are a couple of my steel load patterns to give you an idea of the differences in performance you might see.
The loads were shot through a Remington 870 Special Purpose shotgun with a 26-inch...
Here are some of my pattern numbers with those two loads to give you an idea of their performance in my gun/chokes.
Even though the Speed-Shok patterned a little tighter... If choked for the distance of your shots and provided you can put the pattern on their front end, I doubt a mallard will...
Not sure if I'm an old timer or not but I feel like it some morning!
Shot my first duck in 1968 (I think) and me and my buddies shot our first geese near Salt Plains NWR on 11-27-70. Mine and my buddy's dad took us on the hunt, and we shot 10 Canada geese from a pit blind in a wheat field over...
Sam D3 -- Here are some of my 20-gauge pattern numbers, that I've posted before, to give you an idea of the kind of performance you might get from some 3-inch steel loads. Of course, you’ll need to pattern your gun/chokes/loads to check their performance since they may vary from mine.
Pattern...
I've cut open and counted a few over the years in order to determine true pattern percentages. Here are some of my 12 gauge steel load numbers for your consideration.
12-gauge factory steel load true pellet counts
The true in-shell pellet count listed is an average of five shells cut open and...
That may depend on the load, the barrel, and the choke.
Patterning results from a 12-gauge Browning Citori with 28" Invector-plus barrels using Briley flush chokes (patterns average of five, 30" post-shot scribed circle, yardage taped muzzle to target, and in-shell pellet count average of...
Ok, an old post but I'll chime in with some of my patterning info that I've posted before in case any newcomers haven't seen it.
Patterning results from a 12-gauge 3-inch Remington 870 Special Purpose with a 28-inch barrel and factory flush Rem-chokes (pattern average of five, 30-inch post-shot...
IMHO -- A 12ga 2 3/4-inch 1 1/4-ounce of #5 lead at 1220 fps is the best pheasant load on the market. Regardless of brand, they should be pheasant killers if choked appropriately for the distance of your shots!
Here are a few of my pattern numbers comparing that load with a couple other...
I didn't say so, the pattern board says they perform the same!
40 YARD patterns
Mean pattern / 253.1 (71.05%)
Mean pattern / 254.9 (69.22%)
That's crazy close to the same performance on a 10-shot average!
I didn't assess functioning ability of the two through SA guns but I can tell you that...